Humans Have Made Dogs Helpless

Humans Have Made Dogs Helpless!

Dogs have a tendency to stay behind and await encouragement when facing a difficult task. Their close relationship with humans has made them almost helpless when they have to perform a task on their own a new study reveals.

Typically, dogs have been clever enough to take care of themselves, but perhaps their tight relationships with humans have made them more likely to quit when facing a difficult task.

At least, that’s what a new behavioral study from Oregon State University shows, according to

Humans Have Made Dogs Helpless!

Perhaps we should start to reconsider if it really is a sign of high intelligence that dogs are capable of asking humans for help, the scientist behind the study thinks.

“People have a tendency to think of dogs as intelligent beings, because they understand when a problem can’t be solved, unlike wolves who don’t understand such a situation.”

– Monique Udell, ph.d. and lecturer at Oregon State University

This study has been published in Biology Letters.

Pull a String – Receive a Sausage

For her research, Monique Udell had 10 dogs raised as pets, and 10 wolves raised by humans.

She also used 10 dogs from a shelter, to be used as a sort of middle ground between the wolves, and the pet dogs.

A scientist (or the dogs’ owner for those that were pets) called for the animals’ attention and gave the animal the scent of a sausage. Then they placed the sausage in a transparent plastic container and placed a lid from where a piece of string protruded.

To get the sausage, the dog, or the wolf, just had to pull hard on the string while locking the container with its’ paws.

The Dogs Quit

The researchers made two different tests, each lasting two minutes:

  • During the first test, a human stood near the animal while the test went on.
  • During the second test, the animal was allowed to solve the task, without any humans nearby.

In both tests, the wolves were able to open the plastic container and get to the sausage. The same was only the case with one of the dogs from the shelter with no humans around, and for one of the pet dogs with their owner close by.

“The pets seem to prefer being cautious, even if they could easily solve the problem by themselves, and their owners signaling that it’s ok. They prefer a socially cognitive solution.”

– Monique Udell

Positive Reinforcement Helped the Dogs

To further test their suspicions, the researchers repeated the test with those dogs that weren’t able to solve the test in the first round, but this time the human beside them was constantly encouraging the dog.

This encouragement had an instant effect: suddenly, 4 of the dogs from the shelter were able to solve the problem, and it also worked for one of the pet dogs. And on top of that, it was very clear how committed the dogs were to solving the problem.

“It’s not that the dogs can’t do it, but they don’t even try unless they are socially motivated”

– Monique Udell

Dogs’ Aren’t Stupider Than Wolves

Humans Have Made Dogs Helpless

According to Brian Hare, an evolutionary anthropologist at Duke University in North Carolina, it’s not a sign that dogs are less intelligent than wolves when they prefer having humans help them with their tasks.

“it’s natural for wolves to be independent problem solvers, and for dogs to be able to read human signals.”

– Brian Hare

Behavior biologist Zsófia Virányi of Wolf Science Center in Austria says it’s unclear if dogs and wolves are equally motivated when facing the same task. Perhaps the wolves were just more eager to get the food.

Or perhaps the simple explanation is as Monique Udell suggests, also the correct one: that modern dogs simply aren’t capable of taking care of themselves, as they always have humans nearby.


Some of My Favorite Products For Dog Owners

I hope this article has helped you just a bit in everyday life as a dog owner. Being a dog owner for more than 25 years, I’ve tried many different products with varying success, but these products below are some that I can highly recommend to every dog and their owner without hesitation!

These links are affiliate links, so if you do end up using the links, I will earn a commission. But it’s products that I use daily myself, and I have the utmost praise for.

Dog Food: Every dog needs to eat correctly, and finding the best food for your dog can be challenging, as the market is absolutely flooded with products. But since 2015 when the company was founded, I’ve been using Ollie Petfood. With their product being tailor-made to suit every dog’s specific needs, and as my dogs love the product, I’m pretty sure I’ve found a product I will continue to use for many years more. If you use my link you can get 50% off your first order.

Dog Training: If you’ve ever owned a puppy, you know that it requires a lot of training to grow into a well-behaved adult. Brain Training for Dogs has helped me immensely with the mental training part of raising a dog, and it’s something I strongly recommend you consider.

Grooming: If you have a dog in your home, you’re going to need a brush, and for this, I recommend a Hertzko Self-Cleaning Slicker Brush. For that price, you simply can’t beat this brush for everyday grooming.

If you’re looking for the most up-to-date recommendations, check out my recommended products section that I’ve created to help every dog owner!